In their heyday, unions represented 36 percent of the American workforce.
How things have changed.
Now, that number stands at only 12 percent, and when you factor out the public-sector unions, the number plummets to a paltry 7 percent.
While unions were formed for good reasons — to combat deplorable working conditions and slave labor wages — shortsighted union leaders have made a habit of biting the hand that feeds them. Ironically, the biggest casualty to organized labor’s greed are the rank-and-file members, as evidenced by the numbers above.
It is precisely for this reason that union leaders are the driving force behind card check legislation, which would eliminate the secret ballot in union elections. While admitting to themselves that this is an inherently un-American tactic, labor leaders see card check as the only viable way to preserve the union movement.
Funny, but something else much more simplistic comes to mind that would achieve the same objective — without violating a member’s right to secretly cast a vote.
Common sense.
But for that, there is one prerequisite: you have to live in this world.
Not upper Uranus.
So for a classic case study of how space cadets operate, let’s take a look at the ongoing legalized extortion occurring in the Neshaminy School District.
The teachers union in that Bucks County district has been at odds with the school board for months. Why?
Because they want a “fair” contract.
Pretty much everyone else on this planet calls it greed. Unadulterated greed.
What are they asking from the taxpayers? Salary increases, retroactive to 2008, of 2.75 percent in each of the first two years, 3 percent in the third and fourth years, and 3.5 percent in the final year.
So a teacher making $100,000 a year now will be taking home a guaranteed $116,000 salary for nine months’ work in 2013. What a deal!
And there are quite a few teachers at or near that level: 64 make over $100,000, and over half make over $90,000, not including health care benefits.
But hey, times are tough, so the union leadership has another demand, one from which it won’t budge: continued free health care.
That’s right. Neshaminy teachers do not pay a single penny towards their health care premiums.
Nothing. Nada. Zip.
How’s that for living in the real world?
Instead, the forgotten taxpayer foots the bill for their high-end plan, to the tune of around $27,000 per teacher, per year.
And it doesn’t stop there.
The taxpayers’ largesse also extends to Neshaminy’s retired teachers, many with lucrative pensions (some over $100,000 per year) who also enjoy free healthcare.
But in the private sector — that forgotten place which employs the people who pay for all the teachers’ salaries and benefits — pay raises in today’s economy are the exception, and employees typically shoulder at least 30 percent of their healthcare costs.
Not content with the negotiations, however, the teachers showed their “class” by repeatedly boycotting Back to School Nights. In addition, their classrooms aren’t decorated, bulletin boards remain vacant, recommendation letters are on hold — and reports have stated that the contract dispute has been discussed in the classrooms, which is the very last place it belongs.
But hey, the union’s demands have nothing to do with greed, we are nauseatingly told. No, no…. it’s all about the children!
Sure it is.
And pigs can fly.
* * *
Speaking of the airborne Neshaminy union leaders, let’s discuss the real issue. You know, the one that everyone — parents, teachers and union officials — pretend isn’t there.
Our educational product is failing.
All across Pennsylvania, and yes, in Neshaminy, too.
The beauty of math is that numbers don’t lie. And Neshaminy’s numbers are dismal.
Only 67 percent of the district’s 11th graders are proficient in reading. In math, it’s 72 percent.
So let’s tell it like it is: one-third of Neshaminy’s students can’t read proficiently and almost the same number can’t add or subtract.
And the real number is even higher, since students who have already dropped out of school — a significant number — aren’t counted.
Yet the taxpayers are pumping out $17,000 per student, per year. And the results?
Pure mediocrity.
Getting a 67 on a test is an F. In the real world, being content with a 67% success rate is unacceptable.
* * *
Several weeks ago, Governor Rendell celebrated the news that 82 percent of our schools met basic benchmark levels.
And that’s reason to celebrate? Maybe for Venezuela, but not the United States of America.
Since when did we aspire to be average? To be simply… mediocre?
Worst of all, to actually be happy with that? That’s not how we put a man on the moon, nor was it how we became the most powerful and prosperous nation in the world.
Shame on the Governor for setting such a poor example, which should come as no surprise.
He’s always been in bed with the teachers’ unions.
We lead the nation in school strikes almost every year, are near the top in teacher salary and benefits, but are perpetually close to the bottom in literacy, graduation rates, SAT scores, and students going on to college.
What Rendell and the unions’ leadership haven’t yet realized is that we’re no longer competing against Bubba Cletus who at 19 is getting out of 7th grade. We’re not even competing against San Francisco and Seattle anymore, but Sydney and Singapore.
Compared to their counterparts in the world’s 30 richest countries, American students are, at best, right in the middle, but more often than not, closer to the bottom.
Average was never good enough, but in an ever-increasing global economy where today’s best students are tomorrow’s world leaders, America is dangerously close to getting blown off the field.
Responsibility for improving education rests with everyone: parents, students and teachers. And make no mistake. There are thousands of dedicated teachers who go the extra mile, making lifelong impressions on our children — our future — in a way few others can. There is no way you can ever put a price tag on truly good teachers and adequately compensate them for the service they perform.
And the good ones understand this. They went into the profession for far more than money.
Unfortunately, these treasures are represented by a union whose actions run contrary to the true mission of the teaching profession. And whether the voices of the good ones are drowned out by the masses, or intimidation rules the day, the end result is disastrous — like Neshaminy.
So cheers to the Neshaminy School Board for not relenting to selfish union leaders who care nothing about the students, and all about grabbing as many tax-payer dollars as possible.
But a few sobering words of caution are in order:
FACT: Throwing more money at the problem has never worked, and never will.
FACT: Higher teacher salaries do not translate into better results.
FACT: Until true accountability is realized — through school choice — the downward trend will only continue, accelerating America’s decline.
Bottom line: unless we make the effort to fix the real problems, we might as well start learning to speak Chinese.
Chris Freind is an independent columnist, television commentator, and investigative reporter who operates his own news bureau, www.FreindlyFireZone.com. Readers of his column, “Freindly Fire,” hail from six continents, thirty countries and all
fifty states. His work has been referenced in numerous publications including The Wall Street Journal, National Review Online, foreign newspapers, and in Dick Morris’ recent bestseller “Catastrophe.” Freind also serves as a weekly guest commentator on the Philadelphia-area talk radio show, Political Talk (WCHE 1520), and makes numerous other television and radio appearances, most notably on FOX 29. He can be reached at CF@FreindlyFireZone.com.





















September 28th, 2010 at 9:26 am
Unfortunately this is a great article. You only shortcomming was to not spending a little more time discussing how the Union’s second great mission (after procuring unjustifiable remuneration) is to protect bad teachers.
Meanwhile Lawrence O’Donnel on MSNBC was telling Joe Scareborough the other day that he had mixed thoughts regarding the NEA’s reccommendation that teachers be given tenure so they could stand up to bad principles (at least they were mixed – which isan improvment for that idiot).
Thank g-d that unlike Mr. O’Donnel, even many liberals are starting to “see the light” regarding the scoundrelous teachers union.
September 28th, 2010 at 12:31 pm
September 28th, 2010 at 3:06 pm
Let’s talk about parents’ involvement in their children’s education too. If you want your child’s score to improve…..ummm….spend some time with them each night and practice reading skills or math or whatever it is that they need help with.
A child can have the best teacher in the world but without parental support and reinforcement it’s useless.
If you don’t like school scores, do something else beside complain. Pick up a book and tutor a kid.
September 28th, 2010 at 4:20 pm
If not for Freind, Philly Mag and FOX 29, we would know nothing.
September 28th, 2010 at 4:41 pm
September 28th, 2010 at 5:35 pm
September 28th, 2010 at 6:44 pm
Your article was on the mark. I have wanted to comment for a long time and I think I have finally found the appropriate forum. I have a question for the teachers, board and taxpayers of the Neshaminy school District. Does anyone else remember the strike of 1981? When the union attempted to turn back the school buses filled with high school students, I walked home, while my father and many other parents frantically searched for their children. Little did I know that I would not be back on school grounds for over three months. As a junior I watched many of my senior friends quit school, get in trouble and/or lose out on the colleges they wanted to go to. I really don’t believe I learned anything that year, except that teacher”s strikes are wrong. I became an educator and have never voted to strike. In New Jersey I was asked to participate in a show of hands to strike, the repercussions of keeping my hand down lasted all year and were subsequently the reason I left that school district. The majority of my family members live in the district and have paid Neshaminy taxes for over fifty years. We deserve our say and quite frankly we deserve better teachers. One last and I think very funny/ironic point- many of my classmates went on to work in education and I know of at least seven of them are employed by the district, and members of the union. I’d love to hear what they have to say as we all watch history repeat itself.
September 28th, 2010 at 9:11 pm
September 28th, 2010 at 9:25 pm
Take away their right to strike, and we will have a real discussion.
Enough is enough.
September 28th, 2010 at 10:28 pm
The trouble with our nation’s schools is that we need to produce more hi-tech graduates in order to return our past high standard of living not just presently to what the teachers have now but for more of us private sector workers. We need more students that usually stand out because they learn early on that thinking is challenging fun. These achievers in technology not only become scientists and engineers but several combine their technical disciplines with the field of medicine and other human sciences. Its individuals such these that make the scientific discoveries that help their fellow man, even one day helping families that have special needs problems, NCLB.
Sports, singing and dancing, artistic endeavors, etc. have there place and largely provide nothing more than entertainment to the masses albeit the jobs provided are mediocre in pay for the many and excessive to a few. I feel the teaching of this area should be done by independent contractor firms and the resultant savings from doing so go toward the best teachers that can restore this countries scientific prowess. The same for privatizing the special needs segment to make it more cost effective and utilize the savings similarly. It is utterly foolhardy to increase employment with personnel who can rapidly rise to six figure salaries and retirements costing millions year after year to meet the swelling ranks of NCLB while the numbers of exceptionally bright students stagnate because extra resources to swell their ranks go toward the burgeoning costs of NCLB. I suggest that every school district publish these figures to make the costs of NCLB known in each school district. These published facts will later serve in good stead as evidence to seek legislative relief on NCLB issues.
Without a more substantial number of young people taking up scientific careers in this country, the multifaceted thresholds of science will be left in waiting for the graduates of competitor nations with their much larger scientific student force. They will also reap the rewards of new home based industries and the good paying jobs that normally follow while the USA languishes in socialism.
September 29th, 2010 at 8:58 am
September 29th, 2010 at 9:47 am
I’m not a teacher in Neshaminy school district. I don’t have a child who attends one of its schools nor do I live in the district. However, I would like you to spend a week, no make it 3 days in a classroom that is riddled with the emotional, social & academic problems that are commonplace in our current public school classrooms. Do that for 3 days knowing that you are the nurse, psychologist, parent, therapist, confidant and teacher. Then think about doing it for 177 more days. Then you can tell me if a veteran teacher who has done this for the past 25 years doesn’t deserve $100,000 for nine months work.
We need to stop thinking of teachers as second class citizens. I have friends from college who entered the work force making this much money. Others work 8-4 and take home annual bonuses $60,000 and up. That’s what’s not fair.
I’m not going to pretend that our school system isn’t messed up. Nor am I going to deny the statistics that show that we are not scoring where we should be compared to the rest of the world. But, articles like this that blast teachers don’t take everything into account and are purely ignorant.
Who are you sleeping with on the school board?
September 29th, 2010 at 10:36 am
Please allow me to respond to your absurd rant.
“Then you can tell me if a veteran teacher who has done this for the past 25 years doesn’t deserve $100,000 for nine months work.” DESERVE??? Who the hell DESERVES to make $100,000 for 9 months of work? I have to assume that this was meant tongue in cheek. NO ONE DESERVES to make that much money off the taxpayers. This entitlement attitude is why teachers are becoming so reviled. The following youtube video is about firefighters but could just as easily be about Neshaminy teachers: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=aap_p8DYEUo
“We need to stop thinking of teachers as second class citizens. I have friends from college who entered the work force making this much money.” Again, you can’t be serious. NO ONE leaving college and entering the workforce at age 22 is making $100,000 for 9 months work. I call BS on your claim.
“Others work 8-4 and take home annual bonuses $60,000 and up. That’s what’s not fair.” FAIR??? Are you kidding me? Are you 12 years old? That is life deal with it.
“Who are you sleeping with on the school board?” If Chris is sleeping with a member of the school board than so is everyone else because no one supports the teachers on this issue. Jenn, are you sleeping with a Neshaminy teacher?
September 29th, 2010 at 10:52 am
Step into a classroom. Try it!
September 29th, 2010 at 1:37 pm
September 29th, 2010 at 1:51 pm
I think the concept of unions is outdated and is long past its expiration date. What the NFT is asking for and is doing is shameful. I too have not, nor will ever vote to go on strike. Unions protect bad teachers and this entire situation gives good teachers bad press. Teachers don’t “deserve” a high salary. Like any other profession, I believe we should have the opportunity to earn more, based on performance. Just like any other job.
However, what this story doesn’t show you is that teachers cannot solely be held accountable for test scores. Test scores do not tell the whole picture. I have students who do not complete homework but yet, their parents made sure they made it to football practice on time. Several students don’t bother to do homework at all because no one at home is checking to make sure they did it, let alone check it to see if it’s correct. Parents pay a big part of their child’s success or failure in education. You cannot lay the blame solely at teachers feet. Look at the test scores of the children whose parents check for homework or help their children learn material when they are struggling and I guarantee you those test score will be higher than what this article represents.
Being a teacher is rewarding and brings me more joy than anything I else I would ever want to do. And if your angry about the overall situation in American education, go volunteer to teach a lesson in a classroom. Teach a writing lesson or come read a book. Anything, just get involved instead of making personal attacks.
And for the record I am not a Neshaminy teacher, but I am a Neshaminy parent.
September 29th, 2010 at 2:15 pm
September 29th, 2010 at 4:20 pm
September 30th, 2010 at 10:22 am
1st, I have friends in other parts of the country who are teachers, most of them make $30 to $60,000 a year to do the same job (non-union). 2nd, I find it hard to believe that any of these individuals chose to go into teaching because of the salary. I think they chose to teach because they love kids and had a dream to make a difference. They are making a difference now, unfortunately.
Our teachers have been spoiled. Their benefit packages far exceed both in expense and coverage what the average person receives from an employer. The pay rate in this already suffering economy is just absurd. .
My profession does require me to continually educate myself as well. The salary I receive varies based on my performance & skills and how I choose (as an individual) to utilize those continuing education credits. I can better myself for more money, or I can choose to be mediocre and accept the salary that goes along with mediocrity.
I met with a teacher of one of my children recently, she became teary eyed over this situation. I watched her fight back tears because she doesn’t agree with what is going on, but because she is a member of the union, she has to go with the masses. She doesn’t agree with the majority on this issue but feels that since she is a very small fish in a very big sea and relatively new to the profession she is obligated to follow the ridiculous rules being imposed. For fear that she will be ostracized for making a stand. How many of the teachers that are members of this union feel that way? How many of them are voting for these unrealistic demands and going along with the masses for fear of repercussions from their co-workers? Is there some bullying going on here?
To generalize “ALL TEACHERS” is like saying because 1 man of a particular race commits a crime, all people in that race are doing the same thing.
There cannot be an increase in salary, the community simply can’t afford it. Teachers have to join the rest of the nation and start helping to pay for their benefits. Sorry guys, but that’s just reality! My husband and I pay $90 each week for crappy health insurance for a family of four. Because we have to.
We were both unemployed due to downsizing and for the first time in our lives had no health insurance for almost a year. We are members of the working poor. We make to much to qualify for any kind of assistance. We’ve struggled for the past 3 years just to make ends meet. BUT….we are fortunate compared to others out there. People have lost their jobs, their homes, their health insurance.
This union and the majority of the teachers are pushing for some seriously unrealistic demands. Stop saying you want what is fair, that this is about the kids. If this were about the kids an agreement would of been made already. If this were about the kids then the teachers would of been present at back to school night, letters of recommendation would be sent, etc… This is about money, pure and simple.
Our children need better learning tools, those friends of mine that teach in other school districts, have computers for the kids, there are smart boards in every classroom. Their students are excelling because their educational systems are finding ways to afford the accomodation of teaching methods that children of today can relate to.
As parents, my husband and I do our part to be involved in the education of our children. We check homework and make our kids study. However, I have noticed something about some of these Neshaminy teachers. My oldest will graduate high school next year. Throughout her entire school career I can count maybe 6 teachers that have actually put forth an effort to assist her when she has needed it. Most of the teachers that she has had, if it required any extra effort for them to teach her something, have just pushed her aside. I’ve asked for conferences, sent emails, wanting to know what is going on with my child. Her IEP has been consistently ignored by those same teachers, while a few over the years have gone above and beyond to try to accomodate the guidelines that are set by that IEP. Last year I requested 3 separate IEP meetings in an attempt to speak with 2 of those teachers, neither of them appeared at any of the 3 meetings nor did they respond to emails sent to them. But those same teachers are bucking for a raise and continued free healthcare!? I can’t say that they deserve it. Raises should be performance based not based on how long you’ve worked for a company/school district. It should be how well you’ve worked for that company or school district.
I hope that those teachers out there that disagree can find a way to stand up for what they believe. I think that there are more of you out there than are coming forward! Stand up! Be heard! Get your contract – a fair one for everyone! Then go to work with your head held high and the satisfaction that standing up for your beliefs gives you! You’ll have the support of the parents! Which in reality is what is needed here anyway…I mean…if it truly is about the kids.
September 30th, 2010 at 1:54 pm
I formerly subscribed to Philadelphia magazine for years but the writing had become so poor I didn’t renew my subscription. With lousy writing, such as this article, I can see the magazine’s writing quality truly has sunk to the level of fishwrap or rag status. I mean come on, “The beauty of math is that numbers don’t lie. And Neshaminy’s numbers are dismal.
Only 67 percent of the district’s 11th graders are proficient in reading. In math, it’s 72 percent.
So let’s tell it like it is: one-third of Neshaminy’s students can’t read proficiently and almost the same number can’t add or subtract.”
So 28 percent can’t add or subtract (BTW FYI 28 percent is closer to one-quarter, 25 percent, than one-third, 33 percent)? How does proficiency in 11th grade math equate to inability to add or subtract? I would think proficiency in math in 11th grade has more to do with advanced algebra, geometry, statistics, pre-calculus, and calculus; not mere addition and subtraction. I think we need to institute logic classes in EVERY curriculum in the state. The only downside to that is if everyone that graduated high school were proficient in logic, illogical people couldn’t fool or trick people to believe lies and fallacious and illogical reasoning as easily. Let’s go for it!
September 30th, 2010 at 3:29 pm
September 30th, 2010 at 10:22 pm
October 1st, 2010 at 9:25 am
October 2nd, 2010 at 11:15 am
October 2nd, 2010 at 12:38 pm
I love it, but look at who he slams in just the last few columns. he shoved it where the sun don’t shine to Ed Rendell, (still very powerful national leader), his Ballard Spahr law firm (also extremely rich and powerful), the teachers unions, the DRPA, Michael Nutter, Mike Castle and the nation Republicans, Brian Tierney , also linked in with some pretty rich players, . And of course, the TEAMSTERS!!
Yeah buddy!!.
WTF???!!! Who does that?
This is just too good to see come to an end! Let the rats flee! Keep up the Freindly Fire, but wear a bulletproof vest!
October 3rd, 2010 at 12:54 pm
Teachers of Neshaminy PLEASE realize that we can’t pay you any more! We don’t have it! Our kids need health care that we have to pay for, food to eat that we have to pay for and a roof over their heads that we have to pay for! Please speak up! I know a lot of you don’t like what is going on – SPEAK UP!
October 4th, 2010 at 11:15 am
October 4th, 2010 at 1:16 pm
October 5th, 2010 at 10:24 pm
October 16th, 2010 at 8:57 am